|
|||||
|
UN Performance Problems UN Management Accountability Struggles Where is the Rule of Law? Inadequate UN Oversight Recent Developments
|
|
The first list
contains the "Top 50-plus" most useful and relevant sources that IO Watch
has found from all sources (with some preference given to the most recent
materials). They are drawn
from four separate lists, also of 50-plus items each, which follow: books,
reports, articles, and mixed sources dealing specifically with UN field
operations. The Internet makes
many recent reports, and some articles, easily available in full, and
information about most books can also now be found at sites like
amazon.com or barnesandnoble.com.
In order not to encumber the "Top-50-plus overall sources" list
which follows, web citations are included only in the same entries in the
other topic lists: (for instance, item 5. in the "overall" list is at
"A-1" of the articles list).
Further online citations are found starting at "R-1" for reports,
and "FO-2" for available documents on field operations.
These five lists were
updated in July 2006. They
will be further updated and revised periodically. IO Watch notes that the media
reporting on UN performance and accountability problems seems to have
increased quite noticeably in 2006, as especially recognizable in the home
page subsection on Overview of IO Watch archive quotes
III and forward.
(Note: includes books, reports,
articles, and materials on UN field operations, informally
assembled by IO Watch, roughly ranked from "most useful" on down, and
subject to change as new sources are added) 1.
Righter, Rosemary, Utopia lost:
The United Nations and world order, Twentieth Century Fund, New York,
1995. 2.
Hazzard, Shirley, Defeat of an ideal: A study of the self-destruction
of the United Nations, Atlantic, Little-Brown, Boston-Toronto, 1973.
3.
Robertson, Geoffrey, Crimes
Against humanity: The struggle for global justice, 2d ed., Penguin
Books, London, 2002. 4.
Barnett,
Michael, Eyewitness to a genocide: The United
Nations and Rwanda, Cornell University, Ithaca NY (USA) and London,
2002. 5.
Claudia
Rosett, "The oil-for-food scam: What did Kofi Annan know, and when did he
know it?", Commentary, May 2004, pp.15-22, and
"UN headquarters renovation: No accountability without transparency", US
Senate, written
testimony of June 20, 2006.
(Both available at A - 1, with many more of her excellent articles
as well.)
6.
Childers, Erskine, with Urquhart, Brian, "Renewing
the United Nations System", Development
Dialogue, 1994:1, Dag Hammarskjöld Foundation, Uppsala, Sweden,
1994. 7.
Hazzard, Shirley, "Breaking Faith, Parts
I and II", The New Yorker, September 25, 1989,
pp.
63-99, and October 2, 1989, pp. 74-96. 8.
Kennedy, Paul, The parliament of man: The past, present, and future
of the United Nations, Random House, New York,
2006. 9.
"Review of the administrative and financial
functioning of the United Nations", General Assembly resolution 48/218, 23
December 1993, esp. paras. I.E. 2-5, and parts
II. and III. [Note: The GA required
establishment of an effective system of management accountability by
January 1995, and urged actions to combat fraud.]
[Note: Available at R-1: the four following, and five other
landmark (or tombstone) General Assembly resolutions or follow-up are at
R-2 through R-10.] 10. "Personnel
questions", General Assembly resolution 47/226
of 30 April 1993, Part II, para. 2. [Note: The GA regretted
Secretariat foot-dragging on administration of justice, and called for an
in-depth review to achieve a "just, transparent, simple, impartial, and
efficient system of internal justice".] (Available at R-2.)
11. "Review of the administrative and financial
functioning of the United Nations", General Assembly resolution 48/218 B
of 29 July 1994, paras. 5 (c)(iv), 6, 7. [Note: The GA established the Office of
Internal Oversight Services, including a new investigation unit with
confidential staff reporting processes.] (Available at R-3.) 12. "Administration of justice
at the United Nations", General Assembly resolution 59/283 of 13 April
2005, preambular paras. and Part IV. [Note: The GA regretted again
that the internal justice system was "slow, cumbersome and costly" and
that reporting on it was very tardy, and decided that the system must be
redesigned with expert advice to be independent and ensure managerial
accountability.]
(Available at
R-9.) 13. "
Investing in the United Nations: for a stronger Organization worldwide",
General Assembly resolution A/RES/60/260 of 8 May 2006, esp. Part I.
[Note"
The GA reaffirmed its oversight role, and the need for greater
accountability of the Secretary-General himself , and called for Mr. Annan
to clearly define and rigorously enforce accountability, without
exception, at all levels.]
(Available at R-10)
14. The management of the United Nations Oil-For-Food
Programme, Independent Inquiry Committee into the United
Nations Oil-For-Food- Programme, (the Volcker report), Vols. I through IV,
September 7, 2005. (Available at R-11.)
15. Bonner, Ray, "Why we went: How the United Nations
turned its back on Somalia and subverted the best chance for peace", Mother Jones, (USA), March-April 1993, pp.
54-60. (Available at
FO-2.) 16. Cain,
Kenneth, Postlewait, Heidi, and Thomson, Andrew, Emergency sex and other desperate measures: A true
story from hell on earth, Hyperion, New York, 2004. 17. Barnett,
Michael and Finnemore, Martha, Rules for the
world: International organizations in global politics, Cornell
University, Ithaca NY (USA) and London, 2004. 18. Ameri,
Houshang,
Fraud, waste and abuse: Aspects of U.N.
management and personnel policies, University Press of America,
Lanham, MD (USA), June 2003. 19. Ameri,
Houshang, Politics of staffing the United Nations
Secretariat, Major Concepts in Politics and Political Theory, Vol. 8,
Peter Lang, New York, 1996. 20. "Reforming the United Nations: Pope Kofi's unruly
flock", The Economist, August 8th, 1998, pp.
17-19.
21. Hegland,
Corine, "United Nations: Whistle-blower ignored" and "Whistle-blowing at
the United Nations", both in the National
Journal (US), March 12, 2005. 22. Schaefer, Brett D., "A progress
report on U.N. reform", The Heritage Foundation, No. 1937, May 19,
2006. (Available at
A - 6.) 23. U.S. General Accountability Office (USGAO), United Nations: Internal oversight and procurement
controls and processes need strengthening: Testimony, GAO 06-701T April
27, 2006, 19 pp. (Available for this and four more
2006 GAO reports at R-12 through - 16.) 24. United States General Accountability Office, United Nations: Reforms progressing, but
comprehensive assessments needed to measure impact, GAO 04-339,
February, 2004. (Available at
R-18.) 25. United States General
Accountability Office, United Nations: Reforms are
progressing, but overall objectives have not yet been achieved,
GAO/NSIAD-00-150 (and also 00-169), May 10, 2000.
26. "United Nations organizational integrity survey",
Final Report, prepared by Deloitte Consulting LLP, June 2004.
(Available at R-20.) 27. Report of the Panel on United Nations Peace
Operations [the "Brahimi report"], UN document A/55/305 -- S/2000/809 of
August 21 2000, esp. p. xiv. Available at R-22.) 28. Kennedy,
David, The dark sides of virtue: Reassessing
international humanitarianism, Princeton University, Princeton and
Oxford, 2004.
29. Rohde,
David, Endgame: The betrayal and fall of
Srebrenica: Europe's worst massacre since World War II, Westview,
Perseus Books, Boulder CO (USA), 1998. [Note: Winner of the
Pulitzer Prize.] 30. Beigbeder, Yves, The internal management of United Nations
Organizations: The Long Quest for Reform, Macmillan,
London and St. Martins, New York, 1997. 31. Dijkzeul, Dennis, and Beigbeder,
Yves, eds., Rethinking international
organizations: Pathology and promise, Berghahn, New York and Oxford
(UK), 2003. 32. Thornburgh,
Dick, Under-Secretary-General for Administration and Management, "Report
to the Secretary-General of the United Nations", [referred to as "the
Thornburgh report"], 1 March 1993. 33. Report of the Commission of Experts on Reforming
Justice at the United Nations, Justice Geoffrey Robertson Q.C.,
(Chairman), Professor Roger Clark, Ousmane Kane, J.D., published by the
United Nations Staff Union, New York, 12th June, 2006.
[Available at R-24.) 34. "The
failed states index", Foreign Policy and the Fund for Peace, Foreign Policy, July-August 2005, pp. 56-65, and
May-June, 2006, pp. 50-58.
35. Melvern,
Linda, Conspiracy to murder: The Rwandan
genocide, Verso, London and New York, 2004.
36. Wheeler,
Nicholas J., Saving strangers: Humanitarian
intervention in international society, Oxford University, Oxford and
New York, 2000.
37. Polman,
Linda, We did nothing: Why the
truth doesn't always come out when the UN goes in, translated by Rob
Bland, Viking, New York and London, 2003, [1997, and rev. ed. published in
Dutch by Rozenberg, Amsterdam, 2002.] 38. United Nations, A study of the capacity of the United Nations
development system [referred to as "the Capacity study," or "the
Jackson report' after Sir Robert Jackson], vols. I, II, DP/5, Geneva,
1969. 39. Muravchik,
Joshua, The future of the United Nations:
Understanding the past to chart a way forward, American Enterprise
Institute, AEI, Washington, D.C., 2005. 40. Shawn, Eric,
The U.N. exposed: How the United Nations sabotages
America's security, Sentinel, Penguin, New York, 2006. 41. Moore, Mike,
A World Without Walls: Freedom, Development, Free
Trade and Global Governance, Cambridge University, Cambridge
(UK),
2003. 42. Wedgwood,
Ruth, "A run for the money: Spin-offs, rivals and UN reform", The National Interest, No. 82, Winter 2005/06,
pp. 76-81.
43. Khanna, Parag,
"United they fall: Why only Bill Clinton can save the U.N.", Harper's Magazine (US), January 2006, pp.
31-40.
44. Shawcross, William, Deliver
us from evil: Peacekeepers, warlords, and a world of endless conflict,
Simon & Schuster, New York, 2000. 45. Hancock, Graham, Lords of poverty: The freewheeling lifestyles, power,
prestige, and corruption of the multi-billion dollar aid business,
Macmillan, London, 1989. 46. Easterly,
William, "The cartel of good intentions", Foreign
Policy, July/August 2002, pp. 40-49. 47. Branigan,
William, "The UN empire: Polished image, Tarnished reality", Washington Post, September 20, 21, 22, and 23,
1992. 48. Gourevich,
Philip, "The optimist: Kofi Annan's U.N. has never been more important and
more imperiled", The New Yorker, March 3,
2003, pp. 51-73. 49. Easterly,
William, The white man's burden: Why the West's
efforts to aid the rest have done so much ill and so little good,
Penguin, New York, 2006.
50. Sen, Amartya,
"The man without a plan: Can foreign aid work?", Foreign Affairs, Vol. 85, No. 2, March/April
2006, 171-177. 51. Bertrand, Maurice, The Third
Generation World Organization, Martinus Nijhoff, Dordrecht, the
Netherlands, 1989. 52. Judicial group on strengthening judicial
integrity, Record of First Meeting, Global Programme Against
Corruption, Working Paper, United Nations, Center for International Crime
Prevention, Vienna, 2000, 2001, 2003, 2005. (Available at R-25.) 53. In the Supreme Court of the United States, Cynthia
Brzak and Nasr Ishak, Plaintiffs, v. United Nations, Kofi Annan, Ruud
Lubbers, Wendy Chamberlain, Werner Blatter, Kofi Asomani, Raymond Hall, A.
W. Bijleveld, Daisy Bukuru, Defendants, Plaintiffs Motion for Leave to
File Complaint in an Original Action and Plaintiffs' Brief in Support and
Complaint, 3d May 2006. Edward Patrick Flaherty, Counsel of
record for Plaintiffs. (Available at
R-26.) 54. Green,
Penny and Ward, Tony, State crime: Governments,
violence and corruption, Pluto, London and Sterling VA (USA),
2004. 55. U.N. headquarters renovation: No accountability
without transparency, U.S. Senate Committee on Homeland Security and
Governmental Affairs, Subcommittee …, Hearings, 6/20/06.
[Available at R-27.) 56. "Report
commenting on United Nations sexual harassment policy", Chadbourne &
Park LLP, New York, March 2001. (Available at R-28.) 57. Burnett, John
S., Where soldiers fear to tread: A relief
worker's tale of survival, Bantam, New York, 2005.
58. Mealer, Bryan,
"Congo's daily blood: Ruminations from a failed state", Harper's Magazine, April 2006, pp. 53-66. [Also,
his previous article on Congo, "In the valley of the gun", Harper's Magazine, May 2004.] 59. Barnett,
Michael, and Duvall, Raymond, Eds., Power in
global governance, Cambridge Studies in International Relations,
Cambridge University, Cambridge (UK), 2005. 60. Singer, Max
and Wildavsky, Aaron, The real world order: Zones
of peace, zones of turmoil, Chatham House, Chatham, NJ (USA),
1993. 61. American interests and UN reform: Report of the Task
Force on the United Nations, United States
Institute of Peace, June 2005, esp. Chapter 3, "In need of repair:
Reforming the United Nations." (Available at
R-29.) 62. The
Stanley Foundation, "Making UN reform work: Improving member
state-Secretariat relations", Report of the twenty-eighth United Nations
issues conference, February 21-23, 1997. 63. Luck, Edward
C., "How not to reform the United Nations", Global
Governance 11 (2005), October-December 2005, 407-414.
64. Maxwell, Simon, "How to help
reform multilateral institutions: An eight-step program for more effective
collective action", Global Governance 11
(2005), October-December 2005, 415-424. 65. UN Joint Inspection Unit, "Accountability and
oversight
in the United Nations Secretariat", UN document A/48/420,
1993.
(Available at R-31.) 66. UN Joint Inspection Unit, "Reporting on the
performance and results of United Nations programmes: Monitoring,
evaluation, and management review components," UN document A/43/124,
1988. 67. Organisation
for Economic Cooperation and Development, Public
sector transparency and accountability: Making it happen, OECD, Paris,
2002. 68. Meron, Theodor, The United
Nations Secretariat: The rules and the practice, Lexington Books, D.C.
Heath, Lexington, MA and Toronto, 1977.
69. Falconer, Peter, Smith, Colin, and
Websert, C.William R., eds., Managing parliaments in the 21st century, IOS and
International Institute of Administrative Sciences, Amsterdam,
2001. 70. Gourevich, Philip, We wish to
inform you that tomorrow we will be killed with our families: Stories from
Rwanda, Farrar, Straous, & Giroux, New York, 1998, and Picador,
London, 1999. 71. Rwanda: The Preventable Genocide, Report of The International
Panel of Eminent Personalities to Investigate the 1994 Genocide in Rwanda
and the Surrounding Events, Organization of African Unity, 7 July 2000, esp.
Chapter 15, (Available at FO - 19.) TOP 50-PLUS BOOKS (Note: informally assembled by IO Watch, roughly ranked from
"most useful" on down, and subject to change as new sources are added)
1.
Righter, Rosemary, Utopia lost: The United Nations and world order,
Twentieth Century Fund, New York, 1995. 2.
Hazzard, Shirley, Defeat of
an ideal: A study of the self-destruction of the United Nations,
Atlantic, Little-Brown, Boston-Toronto 1973. 3.
Robertson, Geoffrey, Crimes
Against humanity: The struggle for global justice, 2d ed., Penguin
Books, London, 2002. 4.
Barnett, Michael and Finnemore, Martha, Rules for the world: International organizations in
global politics, Cornell University, Ithaca NY (USA) and London,
2004. 5.
Kennedy, Paul, The parliament
of man: The past, present, and future of the United Nations, Random House, New York,
2006. 6.
Ameri,
Houshang,
Fraud, waste and abuse: Aspects of U.N.
management and personnel policies, University Press of America,
Lanham, MD (USA), June 2003. 7.
Ameri,
Houshang, Politics of staffing the United Nations
Secretariat, Major Concepts in Politics and Political Theory, Vol. 8,
Peter Lang, New York, 1996. 8.
Beigbeder, Yves, The internal management of United Nations
Organizations: The Long Quest for Reform, Macmillan,
London and St. Martins, New York, 1997. 9.
Dijkzeul,
Dennis, and Beigbeder, Yves, eds., Rethinking
international organizations: Pathology and promise, Berghahn, New York
and Oxford, 2003. 10. Muravchik,
Joshua, The future of the United Nations:
Understanding the past to chart a way forward, American Enterprise
Institute, AEI, Washington, D.C., 2005. 11. Shawn, Eric,
The U.N. exposed: How the United Nations sabotages
America's security, Sentinel, Penguin, New York, 2006.
12. Moore, Mike,
A World Without Walls: Freedom, Development, Free
Trade and Global Governance, Cambridge University, Cambridge
(UK),
2003. 13. Bertrand, Maurice, The Third
Generation World Organization, Martinus Nijhoff, Dordrecht, the
Netherlands, 1989. 14. Green, Penny
and Ward, Tony, State crime: Governments, violence
and corruption, Pluto, London and Sterling VA (USA), 2004.
15. Barnett,
Michael, and Duvall, Raymond, Eds., Power in
global governance, Cambridge Studies in International Relations,
Cambridge University, Cambridge (UK), 2005. 16. Singer, Max
and Wildavsky, Aaron, The real world order: Zones
of peace, zones of turmoil, Chatham House, Chatham, NJ (USA),
1993. 17. Meron, Theodor, The United
Nations Secretariat: The rules and the practice, Lexington Books, D.C.
Heath, Lexington, MA (USA) and Toronto, 1977.
18. Falconer, Peter, Smith, Colin, and
Websert, C.William R., eds., Managing parliaments in the 21st century, IOS and
International Institute of Administrative Sciences, Amsterdam,
2001. 19. Butler, Richard, The greatest
threat: Iraq, weapons of mass destruction, and the growing crisis of
global security, Public Affairs, New York, 2000. 20. Gold, Dore, Tower of Babble:
How the United Nations has fueled global chaos, New York, Crown Forum,
2004.
21. Sanjuan, Pedro
A., The UN gang: A memoir of incompetence,
corruption, expionage, anti-semitism, and Islamic extremism at the UN
Secretariat, Doubleday, New York, London, 2005. 22. Naím, Moisés, Illicit: How smugglers,
traffickers and copycats are hijacking the global economy, William
Heinemann, London, 2005. 23. Heller, Peter
S., Who will pay? Coping with aging societies, climate
change, and other long-term fiscal challenges, International Monetary
Fund, Washington, D.C., 2003. 24. Steiner, Henry J., and Alston, Philip, International human rights in context: Law, politics,
morals, [Text and materials], 2d ed., Oxford University, Oxford and
New York, 2000. 25. Pietila, Hilkka, and Vickers, Jeanne, Making women matter: The role of the United
Nations, updated and expanded ed., Zed, London and New Jersey,
1994. 26. Jahan, Rounaq,
The elusive agenda: Mainstreaming women in
development, University Press, Dhaka, and Zed, London and New Jersey,
1995. 27. Caiden, Gerald E., Dwivedi, O. P., and Jabbra,
Joseph, eds., Where corruption lives,
Kumarian, Bloomfield CN (USA), 2001. 28. Melvern,
Linda, The ultimate crime: Who betrayed the UN and
why, Allison & Busby, London, 1995. 29. White, Nigel D., The United Nations system: Toward international
justice, Lynne Rienner, Boulder, CO (USA), and London,
2002. 30. Alleyne, Mark D., Global lies? Propaganda, the UN and world order,
Palgrave Macmillan, New York, 2003. 31. de Cooker, Chris, ed., International administration: law and management
practice in international organisations, UNITAR, Martinus Nijhoff,
Dordrecht, the Netherlands, 1989. 32. Reinicke, Wolfgang H. and Deng, Francis, Critical choices: The United Nations, networks, and
the future of global governance, International Development Research
Centre, Better World Fund, United Nations Foundation , Ottawa, 2000.
33. Simmons,
P. J., and de Jonge Oudraat, Chantal, eds., Managing global issues: Lessons learned, Carnegie
Endowment, Brookings Institution, Washington, DC, 2001. 34. Lomborg,
Bjorn, Ed., Global crises, global solutions,
Environmental Assessment Institute, Cambridge University, Cambridge and
New York, 2004, and How to spend $50 billion to
make the world a better place, Cambridge University (2d rev. ed.,
abridged version of the above book), Cambridge University, New York,
2006. 35. Weiss, Thomas G., and Gordenker, Leon,
eds., NGOs, the UN and global governance,
Lynne Rienner, Boulder CO (USA) and London, 1996. [Chapters
1-11 from Third World Quarterly,
1996.] 36. Held, David, McGrew, Anthony, Goldblatt,
David and Perraton, Jonathan, Global
transformations: Politics, economics and culture, Stanford University,
Stanford, CA (USA), 1999. 37. Beigbeder, Yves, Management
problems in United Nations organizations: Reform or decline?, Frances
Pinter, London, 1987. 38. Hazzard,
Shirley, Countenance of truth: The United Nations
and the Waldheim case, Viking Penguin, New York and London, 1990. 39. Elmandjra, Mahdi, The United Nations system: An analysis, Faber and
Faber, London, 1973. 40. Urquhart, Brian and Childers, Erskine,
A world in need of leadership: Tomorrow's United
Nations: A fresh appraisal, revised second edition, Dag Hammarskjold
Foundation and Ford Foundation, Uppsala, Sweden, 1996. 41. Carpenter, Ted Galen, ed., Delusions of grandeur: The United Nations and global
intervention, Cato Institute, Washington, D.C., 1997. 42. Harrod, Jeffrey, and Schrijver, Nico,
eds., The UN under attack, Institute of Social
Studies, the Hague, Gower, Aldershot, England, 1988. 43. Adams, Guy B., and Balfour, Danny L., Unmasking administrative evil, Sage, Thousand
Oaks CA and London, 1998. 44. Pitt, David and Weiss, Thomas G., eds.,
The nature of United Nations bureaucracies,
Croon Helm, London & Sydney, 1986. 45. Florini, Ann M., Ed., The third force: The rise of transnational civil
society, Japan Society for International Exchange and Carnegie
Endowment, Tokyo and Washington DC, 2000. 46. Franck, Thomas M., Nation against nation: What happened to the U.N.
dream and what the U.S. can do about it, Oxford University, New York
and Oxford, 1985. 47. Coicaud, Jean-Marc, and Heiskanen,
Veijo, eds., The legitimacy of international
organizations, United Nations University, Tokyo, New York, Paris,
2001. 48. Schechter, Michael G., Ed., United Nations-sponsored world conferences: Focus on
impact and follow-up, United Nations University, Tokyo, 2000.
49. Claude, Inis L., Swords into plowshares: The problems and progress of
international organizations, 4th ed., Random House, New York,
1971. 50. Joyner, Christopher C., ed., The United Nations and international law, The
American Society of International Law (ASIL) and Cambridge
University, Cambridge and New York,
1997.
51. Reymond, Henri, and Mailick,
Sidney, International personnel policies and
practices, Praeger, New York, 1985. 52. Jordan, Robert S., et al., International organizations: A comparative approach
to the management of cooperation, fourth ed., Greenwood/Praeger,
Westport, Conn., 2001. 53. Light, Paul C., Monitoring government: Inspectors General and the
search for accountability, Brookings, Washington, D.C., 1993. 54. Crocker, Chester A., Hampson, Fen Osler, and Aall,
Pamela, eds., Herding cats: Multiparty mediation
in a complex world, United States Institute of Peace, Washington, DC,
1999. 55. Meisler, Stanley, United
Nations: The first fifty years, Atlantic Monthly, New York, 1995. 56. Jabbra, Joseph G., and Dwivedi, O. P., Eds., Public service accountability: A comparative
perspective, Kumarian, West Hartford, Conn., USA, 1989. 57. Moynihan, Daniel Patrick with Suzanne Weaver, A dangerous place, Atlantic Monthly, Little,
Brown, Boston, Toronto, 1978. 58. Pines, Burton Yale, ed., A world without a U.N.: What would happen if the U.N.
shut down, The Heritage Foundation, Washington, DC, 1984. 59. Rutherford, Paul, Endless propaganda: The advertising of public
goods, University of Toronto, Toronto, Buffalo NY (USA), London,
2000. 60. Williams, Ian, United Nations for beginners, Writers and
Readers, New York, 1995. 61. Padelford, Norman J. and Goodrich,
Leland M., eds., The United Nations in the
balance: Accomplishments and prospects, Praeger, New York, 1965. 62. Richter, William L., Burke, Francis,
and Doig, Jameson W., Combating corruption:
Encouraging ethics, American Society for Public Administration,
Washington, D.C., 1990. 63. Hazzard, Shirley, People in
glass houses, Macmillan, Australia [reissued by Penguin, New York,
1988], 1967.
TOP 50-PLUS REPORTS (Note: informally assembled by IO Watch, roughly ranked from
"most useful" on down, and subject to change as new sources are added)
1.
"Review of the administrative and financial
functioning of the United Nations", General Assembly resolution 48/218, 23
December 1993, esp. paras. I.E. 2-5, and II.
and III. [Note: The GA required
establishment of an effective system of management accountability by
January 1995, and urged actions to combat fraud.] [Further note: This and the following (and almost
all) GA resolutions, by number, are available
in full online at www.un.org/documents
back to 1946, by number, in this case "A/RES/48/218.". General Assembly documents are available there as well, but --
regrettably -- only for the most recent five years. 2.
"Personnel
questions", General Assembly resolution 47/226
of 30 April 1993, Part II. [Note: The GA regretted
Secretariat foot-dragging on administration of justice, and called for an
in-depth review to achieve a "just, transparent, simple, impartial, and
efficient system of internal justice".]
(Available at www.un.org/documents.)
.
3.
"Review of the administrative and financial
functioning of the United Nations", General Assembly resolution 48/218 B
of 29 July 1994, paras. 5 (c) (iv), 6, 7. [Note: The GA established the
Office of Internal Oversight Services including a new investigation unit
with confidential staff reporting processes.]
(This resolution, inexplicably, is not
available online at www.un.org/documents
, but is available at www.un.org/Depts/oios,
under "About Us", "Mandate.")
4.
"Establishment of the Office of Internal Oversight
Services", Secretary-General's Bulletin, ST/SGB/273, 7 September 1994,
section IV.D, "Investigations." [Note: As the General
Assembly required, the Secretary-General established confidential staff
reporting of wrongdoing (i.e., whistleblowing) with careful safeguards,
full due process and fairness, and firm protection of staff against
reprisals.] (Available at
www.un.org/Depts/oios, under
"About Us", "Mandate.")
5.
"Terms of reference for investigations by the [OIOS]:
'Mismanagement, misconduct, waste of resources and abuse of
authority",
ST/IC/1996/29 of 25 April 1996. [Note: Presents, for
staff,
OIOS procedures for confidential and protected staff reporting of
wrongdoing, and OIOS action thereon.] (Available at www.un.org/Depts/oios, under
"About Us", "Mandate.")
6.
"Human
resources management", General Assembly resolution 51/226 of 3 April 1997,
Part I, paras. 2-4, and Part II, preambular and paras. 2-6.
[Note: The GA regretted with "deep concern" poor progress in
establishing a management accountability system with sanctions, and
requested decisive action from Secretary-General Annan.]
(Available at www.un.org/documents.)
7.
"Financial reports and audited financial statements,
and reports of the Board of Auditors," General Assembly resolution 51/225
of 3 May 1997, paras. 11 and 12. [Note: The GA
noted with "deep concern" reports of fraud, and requested
Secretary-General Annan to establish disciplinary actions, better
accountability, and greater managerial control.]
(Available at www.un.org/documents.)
8.
"Review of the implementation of General Assembly
resolutions 48/218B and 54/244", General Assembly resolution 59/272 of 23
December 2004, paras. 6-7. [Note: The GA emphasized
the need (as in 1993) for "real, effective" accountability mechanisms, and
regretted that such mechanisms were not in place, thereby impairing UN
functioning.]
(Available at www.un.org/documents.)
9.
"Administration of justice at the United Nations",
General Assembly resolution 59/283 of 13 April 2005, preambular paras. and
Part IV. [Note: The GA regretted
again that the internal justice system was "slow, cumbersome and costly"
and that reporting on it was very tardy, and decided that the system must
be redesigned with expert advice to be independent and ensure managerial
accountability.] (Available at www.un.org/documents.)
10.
"
Investing in the United Nations: for a stronger Organization worldwide",
General Assembly resolution A/RES/60/260 of 8 May 2006, esp. Part I.
[Note"
The GA reaffirmed its oversight role, and the need for greater
accountability of the Secretary-General himself , and called for Mr. Annan
to clearly define and rigorously enforce accountability, without
exception, at all levels.] (Available at www.un.org/documents.)
11.
The management of the
United Nations Oil-For-Food Programme, Independent Inquiry
Committee into the United Nations Oil-For-Food- Programme, (the Volcker
report), Vols. I through IV, September 7, 2005.
(Available at www.iic-offp.org/
under "Documents.")
12.
U.S. General
Accountability Office (USGAO), United Nations:
Internal Oversight and Procurement controls and processes need
strengthening: Testimony, GAO 06-701T April 27, 2006, 19 pp.
(Available at www.gao.gov/new.items/d06701t.pdf.)
13.
USGAO, United Nations:
Procurement internal controls are weak, GAO- 06-577, April 25 2006, 53
pp.
(Available at www.gao.gov/new.items/d06577.pdf.)
14. USGAO, United Nations: Lessons learned from Oil for Food Program indicate the need to strengthen UN internal controls and oversight activities, GAO-06-330, April 2006, 75 pp. (Available at www.gao.gov/new.items/d06330.pdf .)15.
USGAO, United Nations:
Funding arrangements impede independence of internal auditors,
GAO
06-575, April 25 2006, 67 pp. (Note: Available at www.gao.gov/new.items/d06575.pdf
.) 16.
USGAO, United Nations:
Weaknesses in internal oversight and procurement could affect the
effective implementation of the planned renovation, GAO 06-877T, June
20, 2006, 18 pp. (Available at www.gao.gov/new.items/d06877t.pdf.)
17. Assessment of internal controls in the United Nations
Secretariat procurement operations: Final report, Deloitte,
Audit.Tax.Consulting.Financial Advisory, November 30, 2005, 105 pp.
(Available at Google search, with related items, under "Deloitte
consulting UN procurement".) 18.
USGAO, United Nations:
Reforms progressing, but comprehensive assessments needed to measure
impact, GAO 04-339, February 2004. (Available at www.gao.gov/new.items/d04339.pdf.)
19.
USGAO, United Nations:
Reforms are progressing, but overall objectives have not yet been
achieved, GAO/NSIAD-00-169, May 10, 2000. [Also
GAO/NSIAD-00-150, same date]
20.
"United Nations organizational integrity survey",
Final Report, prepared by Deloitte Consulting LLP, June 2004.
(Available at the Government Accountability Project, www.whistleblower.org,
under Search, "UN integrity survey".) 21. "Picture of UN staff: A worldwide
survey: Organized by UN staff for UN staff", Geneva, 25 September
1995.
22. Report of the Panel on United Nations Peace
Operations [the "Brahimi report"], UN document S/2000/809 of
August 21 2000, esp. p. xiv. (Available at www.un.org/documents
under "Security Council", "SG Reports.") 23. Thornburgh, Dick,
Under-Secretary-General for Administration and Management, "Report to the
Secretary-General of the United Nations", [referred to as "the Thornburgh
report"], 1 March 1993. 24. Report of the Commission of Experts on Reforming
Justice at the United Nations, Justice Geoffrey Robertson Q.C., (Chairman),
Professor Roger Clark, Ousmane Kane, J.D., published by the United Nations
Staff Union, New York, 12th June, 2006. (Available on the IO Watch
home page, under "UN War Crimes Judge …")
25. Judicial group on strengthening judicial
integrity, UN Office for Drug Control and Crime Prevention
(UNODC), Global Programme Against Corruption, Vienna, reports on this
topic of 2000, 2001, 2003, 2005. (Available at www.unodc.org/unodc/corruption_judiciary.html.)
26. In the Supreme Court of the United States, Cynthia
Brzak and Nasr Ishak, Plaintiffs, v. United Nations, Kofi Annan, Ruud
Lubbers, Wendy chamberlain, Werner Blatter, Kofi Asomani, Raymond Hall, A.
W. Bijleveld, Daisy Bukuru, Defendants, Plaintiffs Motion for Leave to
File Complaint in an Original Action and Plaintiffs' Brief in Support and
Complaint, 3d May 2006. Edward Patrick Flaherty, Counsel of
record for Plaintiffs. (Available, with
followup materials, on the IO Watch home page, under "US
Supreme Court …") 27. U.N. headquarters renovation: No accountability
without transparency, U.S. Senate Committee on Homeland Security and
Governmental Affairs, Subcommittee …, Hearings, 6/20/06.
(Available at hsgac.senate.gov/Hearings.Detail
.]
28. "Report commenting on
United Nations sexual harassment policy", Chadbourne & Park LLP, New
York, March 2001. (Available on the IO Watch home page
under Legal.) 29. American interests and UN reform: Report of the Task
Force on the United Nations, United States Institute
of Peace, June 2005, esp. Chapter 3, "In need of repair: Reforming the
United Nations." (Available
at www.usip.org
under "Task Force on UN", 2005.) 30. The Stanley Foundation,
"Making UN reform work: Improving member state-Secretariat relations",
Report of the twenty-eighth United Nations issues conference, February
21-23, 1997. 31. UN Joint Inspection Unit, "Accountability and
oversight
in the United Nations Secretariat", UN document A/48/420,
1993. (Available at www.unjiu.org
under "Reports …". JIU/REP/93/5.) 32. UN Joint Inspection Unit, "Reporting on
the performance and results of United Nations programmes: Monitoring,
evaluation, and management review components," UN document A/43/124,
1988.
33. Organisation for Economic
Cooperation and Development, Public sector
transparency and accountability: Making it happen, OECD, Paris,
2002. 34. Gordenker, Leon, The UN tangle: policy formation, reform, and
reorganization, WPF Reports number 12, The World Peace Foundation,
Cambridge, Mass., 1996. 35. UN Joint Inspection Unit,
"Accountability, management improvement, and oversight in the United
Nations System", Parts I and II, UN document A/50/503, 1995. (Available at
www.unjiu.org
under "Reports …", JIU/REP/95/2, parts I and II.) 36. Fromuth, Peter, Director,
United Nations Management & Decision-Making Project UNA-USA, The U.N. at 40: The problems and the
opportunities, United Nations Association of the United States of
America, New York, June 1986. 37.
United Nations, Report of the
Group of High-Level Intergovernmental Experts to Review the Efficiency of
the Administrative and Financial Functioning of the United Nations,
[referred to at the "Group of 18" report], UN document A/41/49,
1986. 38.
Non-Application of
International Law by the ILO Administrative Tribunal: Possible legal
avenues for establishing responsibility, Amsterdam International
Law Clinic, July 2004. [Note: Available on the IO
Watch home page under Legal.] 39. UN Joint Inspection Unit, "Inspection of the
application of United Nations recruitment, placement, and promotion
policies", Parts I and II, UN documents A/49/845 and A/51/656, 1995 and
1996.
(Available at www.unjiu.org
under "Reports …", JIU/REP/95/1 and 96/6.) 40.
Lister, Frederick K., United Nations Management and
Decision-Making Project UNA-USA, Fairness and
accountability in U.N. financial decision-making, United Nations Association
of the United States of America, New York, 1986.
41.
Deepak Nayyar and Julius Court, Governing globalization: Issues and Institutions,
Policy Brief No. 5, United Nations University and World Institute for
Development Economics Research (WIDER), Helsinki, Finland,
2002. 42.
Joint Inspection Unit, "Management in
the United Nations: Work in progress", UN document
A/50/507,1995. (Available at www.unjiu.org
under "Reports …", JIU/REP/95/8.) 43.
Bertrand, Maurice, "Some reflections on the reform of
the United Nations", UN Joint Inspection Unit, JIU/REP/85/9, October
1985. 44.
Nordic UN Project 1996 in the Economic and Social
Fields, The United Nations in development:
Strengthening the UN through change: Fulfilling its economic and social
mandate, GCSM AS, Oslo, December 1996. 45. Finger, Seymour Maxwell and Mugno,
John, The politics of staffing the United Nations
Secretariat, The Ralph Bunche Institute on the United Nations, City
University of New York, December 1974. 46. UN Joint Inspection Unit, "Reporting to
the Economic and Social Council", UN documents A/39/281 and Adds. 1 and
2, 1984.
47. Berthoin, Georges, and Luff, Peter, The reform of the United Nations, pamphlet series
on Global Responsibility, One World Trust, 04 February 2005, available
at www.oneworldtrust.org.
48. Luck, Edward C., Reforming
the United Nations: Lessons from a history in progress, Occasional
Papers, 2003 No. 1, Academic Council on the United Nations System, Yale,
2003. 49.
Kovach, Hetty, Neligan, Caroline, and Burall, Simon,
The global accountability report 1 2003: Power
without accountability?, The One World Trust, Houses of Parliament,
London, 2002/2003. 50.
The Stanley Foundation, The
United Nations: 1. Conflict management; 2. Effective
administration, Muscatine, Iowa, USA, 1983. 51.
Bertrand, Maurice, United Nations
Management & Decision-Making Project UNA-USA, Planning, programming, budgeting and evaluation in
the United Nations, United Nations Association of the United States of
America, New York, 1987. 52. Renninger, John P., "ECOSOC: Options for
reform", Policy and Efficacy Studies No. 4, United Nations Institute for
Training and Research, New York, September 1981. 53. Fromuth, Peter and Raymond,
Ruth, U.N. personnel policy issues, United
Nations Management and Decision-Making Project, UNA-USA, New York, June
1987. 54. UN Joint Inspection Unit,
"Report of
the Joint Inspection Unit on personnel problems in the United Nations",
parts I and II, UN document A/8454 (Parts I and II), 5 October
1971. 55. Halper, Stefan, A miasma of corruption: The United Nations at 50,
Cato Policy Analysis No. 253, Cato Institute, April 30, 1996. 56. Nordic UN Project, The, The United Nations in development: Reform issues in
the economic and social fields: A Nordic perspective: Final report,
Almqvist & Wiksell, Stockholm, 1991. 57. UN Joint Inspection Unit, "Toward
a new system of performance appraisal in the United Nations Secretariat:
Requirements for successful implementation', 1994.
(Available at www.unjiu.org, under
"Reports …", JIU/REP/94/5.) 58.
UN Joint Inspection Unit, "Extrabudgetary resources of the United Nations:
Towards transparency of presentation, management, and reporting", UN
document A/45/797, 1990.
(Available at www.unjiu.org,
under "Reports …", JIU/REP/90/3.) 59. Van Houtven, Leo, Governance
of the IMF: Decision making, institutional oversight, transparency, and
accountability, International Monetary Fund, Washington, DC, 2002. 60. The Stanley Foundation, The
United Nations and the future of internationalism, Muscatine, Iowa,
USA, 1987. 61. Renninger, John P., Can the common
system be maintained: The role of the International Civil Service
Commission, United Nations Institute for Training and Research, New
York, 1986. 62. United Nations Management & Decision-Making
Project UNA-USA, A successor vision: The United
Nations of tomorrow, United Nations Association of the United States
of America, Final Panel Report, New York, September 1987. 63. A new United Nations
structure for global economic cooperation: Report of the Group of experts
on the structure of the United Nations system, United Nations,
E/AC.62/9, New York, 1975. 64. Commission on Global Governance, Our global neighborhood: The report of the Commission
on Global Governance, Oxford University, Oxford, 1995.
65. United Nations, World public sector report: Globalization and the
state, Part II, Executive Summary, Division for Public Economics and
Public Administration, New York, 2001. 66. The responsibility to
protect: Report of the International Commission on Intervention and State
Sovereignty, International Development Research Centre, Ottawa,
2001. 67. Organisation for Economic Co-operation
and Development, Voluntary aid for development:
The role of non-governmental organizations, OECD, Paris, 1988. 68. United States General Accounting Office, More can be done to strengthen the U.N. Joint
Inspection Unit, GAO/NSIAD-86-141 of June 1986. TOP 50-PLUS ARTICLES (Note: informally assembled by IO Watch, roughly ranked from
"most useful" on down, and subject to change as new sources are added)
1. Claudia Rosett, "The oil-for-food scam: What did Kofi Annan know, and when did he know it?", Commentary, May 2004, pp.15-22, and ""UN headquarters renovation: No accountability without transparency", written testimony before a US Senate subcommittee on June 20, 2006. The first article is available in full at http://www.commentarymagazine.com/article and the second at hsgac.senate.gov/Hearings.Detail. Many more of her excellent and incisive articles on the UN are available at Google search under "Claudia Rosett."] 2. Childers, Erskine, with Urquhart, Brian, "Renewing
the United Nations System", Development
Dialogue, 1994:1, Dag Hammarskjöld Foundation, Uppsala, Sweden, 1994.
3. Hazzard, Shirley, "Breaking
Faith, Parts I and II", The New Yorker,
September 25, 1989, pp. 63-99, and October 2, 1989, pp. 74-96.
4. "Reforming the United Nations: Pope Kofi's unruly
flock", The Economist, August 8th, 1998, pp.
17-19.
5. Hegland, Corine, "United
Nations: Whistle-blower ignored" and "Whistle-blowing at the United
Nations", both in the National Journal (US),
March 12, 2005.
6. Schaefer, Brett D., "A progress
report on U.N. reform", The Heritage Foundation, Backgrounder No. 1937,
May 19, 2006.
(An excellent update, available at www.heritage.org, under
"Heritage research", "International Organizations.") 7. Wedgwood, Ruth, "A run for
the money: Spin-offs, rivals and UN reform", The
National Interest, No. 82, Winter 2005/06, pp. 76-81.
8. Khanna, Parag, "United they
fall: Why only Bill Clinton can save the U.N.", Harper's Magazine (US), January 2006, pp.
31-40. 9. Branigan, William, "The UN
empire: Polished image, Tarnished reality", Washington Post, September 20, 21, 22, and 23,
1992. 10. Gourevich, Philip, "The
optimist: Kofi Annan's U.N. has never been more important and more
imperiled", The New Yorker, March 3, 2003, pp.
51-73. 11. Luck, Edward C., "How not to
reform the United Nations", Global Governance
11 (2005),
October-December 2005, 407-414.
12. Maxwell, Simon, "How to
help reform multilateral institutions: An eight-step program for more
effective collective action", Global
Governance 11 (2005), October-December 2005, 415-424. 13. Moore, Mike, "Multilateral
meltdown: It's time for another walk in the Bretton Woods", Foreign Policy, March/April 2003, pp.
74-75. 14. Biegelman, Martin T.,
"Fraud prevention culture that works", Fraud
Magazine, May-June 2006, pp. 41-44.
15. Easterly, William, "The
utopian nightmare", Foreign Policy,
September-October 2005, pp. 58-64. 16. "What good is international
law?", The Wilson Quarterly, Vol. XXVII, No.
4, Autumn 2003, 21-59. 17. Daalder, Ivo and
Steinberg, James, "The future of preemption", The
American Interest, Vol I., No. 2, Winter 2005, 30-39. 18. Hale, Thomas N., and
Slaughter, Anne-Marie, "Transparency: Possibilities and limitations", Fletcher Forum of World Affairs, Vol 30:1, Winter
2006, 153-164.
19. Fukuyama, Francis, "The
paradox of international action", The American
Interest, Vol I., No. 3, Spring 2006, 30-39.
20. Berman, Evan M., and West,
Jonathan P., "What is managerial mediocrity?", Part I, "Definition,
prevalence, and negative impact", and Part II, "Solutions … : Moving up to
excellence", both in Public Performance &
Management Review (US), Vol. 27 No. 2, December 2003, pp. 9-29, and
30-52.
21. Haines, David W., "Fatal
choices: The routinization of deceit, incompetence, and corruption", Public Integrity, Winter 2003-2004, vol. 6, no.
1, pp. 5-23. 22. Shalala, Donna E., "The buck stops here: Managing large
organizations with honesty and integrity", Public
Integrity, Fall 2004, vol. 6, no. 4, pp. 349-356. 23. Applebaum, Anne, "Is the
UN really necessary?", The Spectator (UK), 31
July 1993, and "An anarchy of
abounding acronyms", The Spectator (UK), 12
November 1994, pp. 9-11. 24. Ali, Aamir, "The international civil service": The
idea and the reality" in de Cooker, Chris, ed., International administration: law and management
practice in international organisations, UNITAR, Martinus Nijhoff,
Dordrecht, the Netherlands, 1989, I.1, pp. 3-20. 25. Salomons, Dirk, "Good intentions to
naught: The pathology of human resources management at the United
Nations," in Dennis Dijkzeul, and Yves Beigbeder, eds., Rethinking international organizations: Pathology and
promise, Berghahn, New York and Oxford, 2003, pp. 111-139.
26. "Bingo! The big
charity bonanza", New Internationalist, NI
383, October 2005, pp. 1-21. 27. Bell, Coral, "The twilight
of the unipolar world", The American Interest,
Vol I., No. 2, Winter 2005, 18-29.
28. Goldgeier, James M., and
Weber, Steven, "Getting to no: The limits of multilateralism", The National Interest, No. 82, Winter 2005/06,
pp. 69-75.
29. Ignatieff, Michael,
"America the mercurial: A new theory predicts when countries will honor or
renege on their international obligations …", legal affairs (US), March-April, 2005, pp.
68-69. 30. Feinstein, Lee,
"UN-divided", The National Interest, No. 82,
Winter 2005/06, pp. 82-86. 31. Rotberg, Robert I,
"Strengthening governance: Ranking countries would help", The Washington Quarterly (US), Winter 2004-05,
pp. 71-81.
32. Bull, Benedicte, Bøås,
Morten, and McNeill, Desmond, "Private sector influence in the
multilateral system: A changing structure of world governance?", Global Governance 10 (2004), October-December
2004, 481-498. 33.
Barnett,
Michael N., and Finnemore, Martha, "The politics, power, and pathologies
of international organizations", International
Organization, vol. 53, no. 4, Autumn 1999, pp. 699-732. 34.
"The world is
watching: A survey of human-rights law", The
Economist, December 5, 1998, pp. 1-16. 35. Joel Krieger, ed., "United Nations", The Oxford companion to politics of the world,
Oxford, London, 2001, pp. 865-874. 36. Fomerand, Jaques, "Recent
UN textbooks: Suggestions from an old-fashioned practitioner", Global Governance, 83(2002), 383-403. 37. Mailick, Sidney, Ed., "Symposium:
Toward an international service", Public
Administration Review (US), Vol. XXX, No 3, May/June 1970, 206-263.
38. Hüfner, Klaus, "Financing the
United Nations: The role of the United States", in Dennis
Dijkzeul, and Yves Beigbeder, eds., Rethinking
international organizations: Pathology and promise, Berghahn, New York
and Oxford, 2003, pp. 29-53. 39. Spiers, Ronald I., "Reforming the
United Nations," in Roger A. Coate, ed., U.S.
policy and the future of the United Nations, Twentieth Century Fund,
New York, 1994. 40. Barnett, Michael, "UN vanquished", Global Governance, 5(1999), 513-520. 41. Quadir, Iqbal Z., "The bottleneck is at the top of
the bottle", The Fletcher Forum of World
Affairs, vol. 26:2, Summer/Fall 2002, 69-89. 42. Segal, Lydia, "Roadblocks in reforming corrupt
agencies: The case of the New York City school custodians", Public Administration Review, July/August 2002,
vol. 62, No. 4, pp. 445-460. 43. Bertrand, Maurice, "The
recruitment policy of United Nations staff", in de Cooker, Chris, ed., International Administration: Law and Management
Practice in International Organisations, UNITAR, Martinus Nijhoff,
Dordrecht, the Netherlands, 1989. 44. Malone, David M., and Thakur,
Ramesh, "UN peacekeeping: Lessons learned?", Global Governance, 7(2001), 11-17. 45. Gallarotti, Giulio M., Ch. 20,
"The limits of international organization: Systematic failure in the
management of international relations", in Diehl, Paul F., ed., The politics of global governance: International
organizations in an interdependent world, Lynne Rienner, Boulder CO,
1997, pp. 375-414. 46. "The United Nations
agencies: A case for emergency treatment", The
Economist, December 2, 1989, pp. 27-30. 47. Reinisch, August, "Securing the accountability of
international organizations", Global
Governance, 7(2001), 131-149.
48. Mathiason, J.R. and Smith, D.C.,
"The diagnostics of reform: The evolving tasks and functions of the United
Nations", in Collins, Paul, ed., "The administrative reform process in
international development organizations", Public
Administration and Development, Special Issue, vol. 7, no. 2, August
1987. 49. Finger, Seymour Maxwell and Hanan, Nina,
"The UN Secretariat revisited", Secretariat
News (New York), 16 October 1980, pp. 9-12 and 31 October 1980, pp.
10-12.
50. Tien-Cheng Young, "The
international civil service reexamined", Public
Administration Review (US), May/June 1970, pp. 217-224. 51. Julia Preston, "A world-class
challenge: Upgrading UN's creaking bureaucracy", International Herald Tribune, January 4,
1995.
52. "Reform or die! The United
Nations at 50", Time, October 30, 1995, pp.
22-47. 53. Jordan, Robert S., et. al, Ch.9,
"Decision making: Muddling through in search of global governance", in International organizations: A comparative approach
to the management of cooperation, fourth ed., Greenwood/Praeger,
Westport, Conn., 2001, pp. 209-232.
54. Rieff, David, "The Millenium
Assembly", Global Governance 7(2001),
127-130. 55. Renninger, John, "The international
civil service commission and the development of a common personel policy
in the United Nations system", Public
Administration and Development, Vol. 7, 1987, 181-194. 56.
Childers,
Erskine, and Urquhart, Brian, "Toward a more effective United Nations", Development Dialogue, 1991:1-2, Dag Hammarskjold
Foundation, Uppsala, Sweden, 1991. 57. "The war on corruption", Public Inquiry, [A publication of the Inspectors
General of the United States], Fall/Winter 2001, pp. 1-62.
58. Mendez, Ruben P., "Financing the United
Nations and the international public sector: Problems and reform", Global Governance 3(1997), 283-310.
59. Naim, Moisés, "The five wars of globalization" ["Why governments
can't stop the illegal trade in drugs, arms, ideas, people, and money"],
Foreign Policy, January/February 2003, pp.
29-37. 60. Van Oudenaren, John, "What is
'multilateral?'", Policy Review (USA),
February & March 2003, pp. 33-47.
61. Wang, Hongying, and Rosenau, James N.,
"Transparency International and corruption as an issue of global
governance", Global Governance, 7(2001),
25-49.
62. Henneberger, Melinda, "Weight of the
world: The United Nations spent the war on the sidelines …. Can Kofi Annan
make it relevant again?", Newsweek , May 26/June
2, 2003, pp. 30-33.
63. Hurd, Ian, "Legitimacy, power, and the symbolic life
of the UN Security Council", Global Governance
8(2002), 35-51.
64. Glennon, Michael J., "Why the
Security Council failed", Foreign Affairs,
May/June 2003. 65. Ottaway, Marina, "Corporatism goes
global: International organizations, nongovernmental organization
networks, and transnational business", Global
Governance 7 (2001), 265-292. 66. Fidler, Stephen, "Who's minding the [World] Bank", Foreign Policy, September/October 2002, 40-50. 67. Alger, Chadwick, "The emerging roles of NGOs in the
UN system: From Article 71 to a People's Millenium Assembly", Global Governance 8 (2002), 93-117.
TOP 50-PLUS SOURCES ON UN FIELD OPERATIONS (Note: includes books,
reports, and articles on UN field operations, informally assembled by IO Watch, roughly ranked from
"most useful" on down, and subject to change as new sources are added)
1.
Barnett, Michael, Eyewitness
to a genocide: The United Nations and Rwanda, Cornell University,
Ithaca NY (USA) and London, 2002. 2.
Bonner, Ray, "Why we went: How the United Nations
turned its back on Somalia and subverted the best chance for peace", Mother Jones, (USA), March-April 1993, pp.
54-60. (Available at www.motherjones.com under "Search",
"Ray Bonner Why we went".) 3.
Cain,
Kenneth, Postlewait, Heidi, and Thomson, Andrew, Emergency sex and other desperate measures: A true
story from hell on earth, Hyperion, New York, 2004. 4.
Kennedy, David, The dark
sides of virtue: Reassessing international humanitarianism, Princeton
University, Princeton and Oxford, 2004.
5.
Rohde,
David, Endgame: The betrayal and fall of
Srebrenica: Europe's worst massacre since World War II, Westview,
Perseus Books, Boulder CO (USA), 1998. [Note: Winner of the
Pulitzer Prize.]
6.
"The
failed states index", Foreign Policy and the Fund for Peace, Foreign Policy, July-August 2005, pp. 56-65, and
May-June, 2006, pp. 50-58.
7.
Melvern, Linda, Conspiracy to
murder: The Rwandan genocide, Verso, London and New York, 2004.
8.
Wheeler, Nicholas J., Saving
strangers: Humanitarian intervention in international society, Oxford
University, Oxford and New York, 2000.
9.
Polman,
Linda, We did nothing: Why the
truth doesn't always come out when the UN goes in, translated by Rob
Bland, Viking, New York and London, 2003, [1997, and rev. ed. published in
Dutch by Rozenberg, Amsterdam, 2002.] 10. United Nations, A study of
the capacity of the United Nations development system [referred to as
"the Capacity study," or "the Jackson report' after Sir Robert Jackson],
vols. I, II, DP/5, Geneva, 1969. 11. Shawcross, William, Deliver
us from evil: Peacekeepers, warlords, and a world of endless conflict,
Simon & Schuster, New York, 2000. 12. Hancock, Graham, Lords of
poverty: The freewheeling lifestyles, power, prestige, and corruption of
the multi-billion dollar aid business, Macmillan, London,
1989. 13. Easterly, William, "The
cartel of good intentions", Foreign Policy,
July/August 2002, pp. 40-49. 14. Easterly, William, The white man's burden: Why the West's efforts to aid
the rest have done so much ill and so little good, Penguin, New York,
2006.
15. Sen, Amartya, "The man
without a plan: Can foreign aid work?", Foreign
Affairs, Vol. 85, No. 2, March/April 2006, 171-177. 16. Burnett, John S., Where soldiers fear to tread: A relief worker's tale
of survival, Bantam, New York, 2005.
17. Mealer, Bryan, "Congo's
daily blood: Ruminations from a failed state", Harper's Magazine, April 2006, pp. 53-66. [Also,
his previous article on Congo, "In the valley of the gun", Harper's Magazine, May 2004.] 18. Gourevich, Philip, We wish to
inform you that tomorrow we will be killed with our families: Stories from
Rwanda, Farrar, Straous, & Giroux, New York, 1998, and Picador,
London, 1999. 19. Rwanda: The Preventable Genocide, Report of The International
Panel of Eminent Personalities to Investigate the 1994 Genocide in Rwanda
and the Surrounding Events, Organization of African Unity, 7 July 2000, esp.
Chapter 15, (Available at the Aegis Trust
website at www.aegistrust.org,
under "Documents", "Rwanda", "OAU report".)
20. Thakur, Ramesh, and Schnabel, Albrecht, eds., United Nations peacekeeping operations: Ad hoc missions, permanent engagement, United
Nations University, Tokyo, New York, Paris, 2001. 21. Ayoob,
Mohammed, "Third-world perspectives on humanitarian intervention and
international administration", Global
Governance 10 (2004), 99-118. 22. Harland,
David, "Legitimacy and effectiveness in international administration", Global Governance, 10 (2004), 15-19. 23. Holt, Victoria K., "UN
peacekeeping reform: Seeking greater accountability and integrity", US
House of Representatives, Committee on International Relations, testimony,
May 18, 2005. (Available at www.stimson.org.)
24. Durch, William
J., Holt, Victoria K., Earle, Caroline R., and Shanahan, Moira K., The Brahimi Report and the future of UN peace
operations,
Henry L. Stimson Center, December 2003.
(Available at www.stimson.org.)
25. Carothers, Thomas, "The
backlash against democracy promotion", Foreign
Affairs, Vol. 85, No. 2, March/April 2006.
26. The quality of money: Donor
behavior in humanitarian financing: An independent study by Ian
Smillie and Larry Minnear, Humanitarianism and War Project, Tufts
University, April 2003. (Available online at www.reliefweb.int/ghd/DonorBehavior.pdf.)
27. Joint progress toward enhanced aid effectiveness:
Harmonization, alignment, results: report on progress, challenges and
opportunities, High-Level Forum, Paris, February 28 - 2 March,
2005. 29. Harland,
David, "Legitimacy and effectiveness in international administration", Global Governance, 10 (2004), January-March 2004,
15-19.
30. Ghani, Ashraf, Lockhart,
Clare, and Carnahan, Michael, "An agenda for state-building in the
twenty-first century", Fletcher Forum of World
Affairs, Vol 30:1, Winter 2006, 101-124.
31. Chesterman, Simon,
Ignatieff, Michael, and Thakur, Ramesh, Eds., Making states work: State failure and the crisis of
governance, United Nations University, Tokyo, 2005.
32. Verweij, Marco, and
Gyawali, Dipak, "Against more aid: Why development assistance should not
be tripled", Harvard International Review,
Winter 2006, pp. 26-30. 33. Carothers, Thomas, Ed., Promoting the rule of law abroad: In search of
knowledge, Carnegie Endowment for International Peace, Washington, DC,
2006.
34. Weiss, Thomas G., ed., Beyond
UN subcontracting: Task-sharing with regional security arrangements and
service-providing NGOs, St. Martins, New York, 1998. 35. Minnear, Larry, The
humanitarian enterprise, Dilemmas and discoveries, Kumarian,
Bloomfield CT (US), 2002. 36. Human
security report: War and peace in the 21st century, Human Security
Centre,
The University of British Columbia, Canada, Oxford University, New
York, Oxford, 2005. (Available at www.humansecurityreport.org.) 37. Rieff, David, A bed for the night: Humanitarianism in crisis,
Simon and Schuster, New York, 2002. 38. Power, Samantha, The problem from hell: America and the age of genocide, Basic Books, New York, 2002. 39. Chandler, David, From Kosovo
to Kabul: Human rights and international intervention, Pluto, London
and Sterling VA (USA), 2002. 40. Maren, Michael, The road to hell: The ravaging effects of foreign aid
and international charity, Free Press, New York, 1997. 41. Harris, Andres, and Dombrowski, Peter,
"Military collaboration with humanitarian organizations in complex
emergencies", Global Governance 8(2002),
155-178. 42. Farmer, Paul, Pathologies of power: Health, human rights, and the
new war on the poor, University of California,
Berkeley, CA (USA), 2003. [With a foreward by Amartya
Sen] 43. Chayes, Antonia Handler, Chayes, Abram,
and Raach, George, "Beyond reform: Restructuring for more effective
conflict intervention", Global Governance,
3(1997), 117-145. 44. Bell, Peter D., and Tousignant, Guy,
"Getting beyond New York: Reforming peacekeeping in the field", World Policy Journal, Fall 2001, pp. 41-46. 45. Jett., Dennis C., Why peacekeeping fails, St. Martins, New York,
2000.
46. Carnegie Commission, Preventing deadly conflict: Final report, New York, 1997. 47. Kosovo
report: Epilogue, Justice Richard Goldstone and the Independent
International Commission on Kosovo, September 2001.
48. Stedman, Stephen John, and Tanner, Fred, eds., Refugee manipulation: War, politics, and the abuse of
human suffering, Brookings Institution, Washington, D.C., 2003.
49. Miskel, James F., and Norton, Richard J.,
"Humanitarian early-warning systems", Global
Governance 4 (1998), 317-329.
50. Ignatieff, Michael, Empire
lite: Nation-building in Bosnia, Kosovo and Afghanistan, Vintage,
London, 2003.
51. Dempsey, Gary, and Fontaine, Roger, Fool's errands: America's recent encounters with
nation building, Cato Institute, Washington, DC, 2001. 52. Jain, Devaki, Women, Development, And The UN: A Sixty-year Quest
For Equality And Justice, United Nations
Intellectual History Project, Indiana University, 2005. 53. "Special issue on governance after
war", Call, Charles T., and Cook, Susan E., eds., Global Governance, 9 (2003), 135-272.
54. Terry, Fiona, Condemned to repeat? The paradox of humanitarian
action, Cornell University, Ithaca N.Y. and London, 2002. 55. Caufield, Catherine, Masters of
illusion: The World Bank and the poverty of nations, Macmillan,
London, 1997. 56. Fink, Sheri, M.D., War hospital: A true story of surgery and
survival, Public Affairs, Perseus, New York, 2003. 57. George, Susan, A fate worse than debt: The world financial crisis
and the poor, rev. updated, Grove Weidenfeld, New York, 1990. 58.
Griffiths, Peter, The
economist's tale: A consultant encounters hunger and the World Bank,
Zed, London and New York, 2003. 59. Hartley, Aidan, The Zanzibar chest: A memoir of love and war,
Harper Collins, London, 2003. 60. La Muniere, C.-H., "Managing the UN's emergency
operations in Africa: Lessons for operational development", in Collins,
Paul, ed., "The administrative reform process in international development
organizations", Public Administration and
Development, Special Issue, vol. 7, no. 2, August 1987. 61. Valentino, Benjamin A., Final
solutions: Mass killing and genocide in the 20th century, Cornell
University, Ithaca NY (USA) and London, 2004. 62. Weitz, Eric D., A century of genocide: Utopias of race and
nation, Princeton University, Princeton NJ (USA) and Oxford (UK),
2003. 63. Stedman, Stephen John, Rothschild, Donald, and
Cousens, Elizabeth M., eds., Ending civil wars:
The implementation of peace agreements, Lynne Rienner, Boulder, CO,
USA, 2002. 64. Anderson, M. N., and Woodrow, P. J., Rising from the ashes: Development strategies in
times of disaster, UNESCO and Westview Press, Paris and Boulder CO
(USA), 1989. 65. Minnear, Larry, Humanitarianism under siege: A critical review of
Operation Lifeline Sudan, Bread for the World Institute on Hunger and
Development, Washington, DC, 1991. 66. Bissell, Richard E., The
United Nations Development Programme: Failing the world's poor,
Heritage Foundation, Washington, D.C., 1985.
67. Collier, Paul, Breaking the
conflict trap: Civil war and development policy, World Bank Policy
Research Report, Oxford University, June 2003.
|
|||